HomeLux Renovations vs Modus Property: which is better for a home extension?
Both firms score close together and both earn strong reputations for tidy sites and communicative teams, so this comes down to how each handles the specific risks of an extension: multi-trade sequencing, timeline certainty, and who is answerable if the job runs long. Based on our methodology, the review data points to different comfort zones for each business.
Verdict
For a home extension, fit comes down to risk tolerance on timeline. HomeLux's review history is thinner but cleaner, built on complex, staged projects with no delay complaints surfacing in the data, making it the safer pick if schedule certainty is the priority. Modus brings a much deeper track record and a bigger team, but two documented cases of subcontractor-driven delays mean an extension (which runs longer and involves more trade handoffs than a kitchen or bathroom) is exactly where that risk could resurface. If you go with Modus, get firm scheduling and contingency commitments in writing before signing.
Which should you pick?
Pick HomeLux Renovations if
- You want a contractor with a specific record on full-home and structurally complex projects
- You want the tightest, most consistent sentiment record with no delay complaints on file
- You'd rather work with a small, stable leadership team (Rob and John) than a larger rotating cast
Pick Modus Property if
- You want a business with a much larger review base to gauge consistency at scale
- Your extension is finish-heavy (kitchen, bathroom) rather than structural
- You're comfortable pressing for detailed scheduling and contingency commitments upfront to avoid the delay pattern some reviewers hit
The differences that matter
- Track record on complex, staged builds. HomeLux's reviews cite full home overhauls and heritage tearouts managed end-to-end, which maps directly onto extension work with structural and trade sequencing demands, while Modus's standout praise skews toward kitchens, bathrooms and finish-level renovations.
- Scheduling risk on longer jobs. Modus has two documented cases of extended delays, including a kitchen reno that stretched from July to November, with contingency planning around subcontractors flagged as the cause, a real concern on a project with an extension's longer timeline; HomeLux's summary has no such complaints on record.
- Review volume and consistency. Modus has almost four times the review base (193 vs 50), giving more data points and a named bench of project managers (Stephen, Tim, Corey, Luke, Mike), while HomeLux's smaller but perfect 5.0 sample centers on Rob and site manager John.
- Sentiment strength. HomeLux's sentiment sub-score (0.81) runs noticeably higher than Modus's (0.64), reflecting that Modus's otherwise strong record carries some real friction on quoting and delays that HomeLux's does not.
Side by side
- Google rating
- HomeLux Renovations: 5 (50 reviews)
- Modus Property: 4.9 (193 reviews)
- Services
- HomeLux Renovations: kitchen renovation, granny flat adu, heritage restoration, full home renovation
- Modus Property: granny flat adu, outdoor alfresco, kitchen renovation, home extensions
- Best for
- HomeLux Renovations: Extensions requiring end-to-end coordination of multiple trades and structural stages
- Modus Property: Extensions bundled with kitchen/bathroom finish work where site presentation matters most
- Team continuity
- HomeLux Renovations: Small, consistent leadership (Rob, site manager John) named across most reviews
- Modus Property: Larger bench of named PMs, useful for capacity but means less guaranteed continuity of a single lead
- Verification
- HomeLux Renovations: Google-verified
- Modus Property: Google-verified
- Composite score
- HomeLux Renovations: 88
- Modus Property: 88
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
HomeLux Renovations
Rob leads a team that consistently delivers on time and on budget, with reviews highlighting how rare that combination feels. From bathrooms to full home overhauls, they communicate at every stage, keep sites tidy, and treat design choices with genuine care.
Site manager John and the broader team work to the same standard. Reviewers name specific projects: laundry overhauls with built-in desks, kitchen tearouts in 1980s homes, outdoor areas, and ensuite installs with gas fireplaces. Several have rehired or recommended friends without hesitation.
Modus Property
Most customers encounter a responsive, well-organised team that delivers polished results on schedule. Corey, Tim, Stephen, Luke, and Mike consistently earn praise for listening to homeowners, communicating clearly, and managing tight budgets without cutting corners. Trades arrive punctually, finish on time, and leave sites spotless.
Two customers faced extended delays and quote mishaps: one waited days for poorly specified quotes; another endured a four-month kitchen reno that stretched from July to November with sparse progress. Both flagged loose contingency planning around subcontractors as the root cause. For most, this risk remains invisible. For complex or time-sensitive jobs, early clarity on scheduling buffers matters.
Can't decide which contractor suits your job?
Tell us about your project once and compare quotes from suitable renovation contractor in Perth metro.
When you submit a form on this site, your enquiry may be shared with partner providers able to do the work. We may receive a referral fee, but our rankings and scores are based on our published method only and are not affected by these fees.
Common questions
- Which business has more experience with extensions specifically?
- HomeLux's review summary references full home overhauls and heritage tearouts, which involve the structural and staging complexity closer to an extension. Modus's strongest praise centers on kitchen and bathroom renovations.
- Has either business had complaints about delays?
- Modus has two documented cases of extended delays, including a kitchen job that ran from July to November, attributed to loose subcontractor contingency planning. HomeLux's review data shows no delay complaints.
- Which has the larger review base?
- Modus Property has 193 Google reviews at 4.9 stars, versus HomeLux Renovations at 50 reviews with a perfect 5.0 rating.